That makes The Incredible True Story Vinyl especially interesting for collectors. But there is an important detail buyers should know: not every copy is equally rare.
The regular black 2LP edition can still be bought as a standard release. The 2016 Record Store Day picture-disc version, however, was produced in a much smaller quantity and has become the version collectors usually chase.
Here is how the releases differ, how to identify what you own, and what actually makes one copy more valuable than another.
What Is The Incredible True Story Vinyl?
The Incredible True Story is Logic’s second full-length studio album. It originally arrived digitally and on CD on November 13, 2015, through Def Jam. Apple Music lists 18 tracks with a running time of just over one hour.
The album has an unusual structure.
Rather than simply moving from song to song, Logic places short scenes throughout the record. Two travelers in the future are searching for a planet called Paradise while listening to Logic’s music. That science-fiction story connects tracks such as:
- Contact
- Fade Away
- Like Woah
- Young Jesus
- City of Stars
- Stainless
- Paradise
- Never Been
- The Incredible True Story
Apple Music describes the record as a widescreen epic built around two space travelers, while Pitchfork’s original review also noted its story taking place roughly a century in the future.
That narrative structure makes the vinyl format feel natural. You are not just dropping the needle on isolated singles. You are moving through an album designed to be heard from beginning to end.
When Did The Incredible True Story Come Out on Vinyl?
Here is where collectors need to separate the album release from the vinyl release.
The album itself came out in November 2015, but the standard U.S. vinyl edition followed on February 26, 2016. Amoeba lists it as a Def Jam 2LP release with catalog number 2427901. Another record retailer identifies the same release as catalog B0024279-01, barcode 602547656568, and a trifold 2LP package.
Then came a much more limited version.
On April 16, 2016, The Incredible True Story received a Record Store Day picture-disc edition. Amoeba identifies that release as a two-LP picture-disc set with Def Jam catalog number 2450801.
The official Record Store Day 2016 release list recorded only 2,000 copies for Logic’s picture-disc edition.
That difference matters enormously when discussing rarity.
Standard 2LP vs Record Store Day Picture Disc
At first glance, two listings for the same Logic album can look strangely far apart in price. Usually, the edition explains why.
| Edition | Release | Format | Collector status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard edition | February 26, 2016 | Black 2LP | Regular commercial release |
| Record Store Day edition | April 16, 2016 | Picture-disc 2LP | Limited to 2,000 copies |
The Standard Black Vinyl
The standard version is the sensible choice if your main goal is owning and playing the album.
Def Jam’s official store currently lists The Incredible True Story as a 2LP, with all 18 tracks spread across four sides. At the time of checking in August 2026, the official store listed it at $19, although prices and availability can change.
The track distribution is:
Side A: Contact, Fade Away, Upgrade, White People (Scene)
Side B: Like Woah, Young Jesus, Innermission, I Am the Greatest, The Cube (Scene)
Side C: Lord Willin’, City of Stars, Stainless, Babel (Scene), Paradise
Side D: Never Been, Run It, Lucidity (Scene), The Incredible True Story.
So if somebody tells you every copy of The Incredible True Story vinyl is extremely rare, that is misleading.
The standard edition is still commercially available.
The 2016 Record Store Day Picture Disc
This is the version where the collector story changes.
The Record Store Day release was a picture-disc edition limited to 2,000 copies. Contemporary coverage described artwork appearing directly on the records, including album imagery and an additional image.
Because the production run was fixed and comparatively small, surviving copies can command much higher asking prices than the regular black LP.
Recent marketplace listings have shown the RSD edition in roughly the $200 to $300 range, although some sellers ask considerably more. Those are asking prices, not proof that every copy is worth that amount.
That distinction can save you a lot of money.
A seller can ask $500 for a record. That does not mean another buyer has actually paid $500.
Is The Incredible True Story Vinyl Rare?
The regular version is not especially rare right now. The 2016 Record Store Day picture-disc version is genuinely limited.
That is the simplest answer.
The official Def Jam store still offers the regular 2LP, which tells us there is continuing supply.
The Record Store Day edition is different because its original run was limited to 2,000 copies.
A run of 2,000 does not automatically make a record incredibly expensive. Demand matters just as much as supply.
Think about it this way.
If only 500 records exist but only 100 people want one, prices may remain modest.
If 2,000 copies exist and 10,000 serious fans want them, competition becomes much stronger.
Logic’s fan base, the album’s reputation, the attractive picture-disc format, and the fixed RSD quantity all help create collector demand.
How Much Is The Incredible True Story Vinyl Worth?
There is no single correct price because you first need to know which pressing you have.
For the standard black edition, the official Def Jam store remains one of the best reality checks. A new copy being offered through the label at a normal retail price makes it difficult to justify calling an ordinary copy extremely valuable.
The RSD picture disc is another story.
Collectors currently encounter listings above $200, but marketplace asking prices vary widely.
Before putting a value on your copy, check five things:
- Edition: Standard black vinyl or RSD picture disc?
- Condition: Scratches, warping and surface marks lower value.
- Sleeve condition: Creases, splits and water damage matter.
- Completeness: Original packaging and inserts can increase collector interest.
- Recent sold prices: Completed sales matter more than ambitious listings.
A sealed copy may bring a premium, but sealed does not automatically mean perfect. Older records can develop storage damage even without being opened.
How Do I Tell If My Vinyl Is an Original?
This question sounds simple until you start collecting records.
An original pressing should match the identifying details of the first release you are trying to authenticate.
For The Incredible True Story, first decide what you mean by original.
If you mean the first regular U.S. vinyl release, records sold in February 2016 are the relevant edition.
Known details include:
Release date: February 26, 2016
Label: Def Jam
Format: 2LP
Catalog references: 2427901 / B0024279-01
Barcode: 602547656568.
If you mean the Record Store Day collectible, look for the 2016 picture-disc edition associated with catalog number 2450801 and the limited RSD release.
Check the Runout Area
One of the most useful clues is not on the cover.
Look at the smooth area close to the center label. This is called the runout or dead wax.
You may see letters, numbers, symbols or stamped markings.
Discogs’ database guidelines explain that matrix and runout information can identify manufacturers, engineers, studios and individual releases. These markings are therefore extremely useful when distinguishing similar pressings.
Compare your record’s:
- Catalog number
- Barcode
- Label design
- Matrix/runout markings
- Country
- Vinyl color or picture design
- Sleeve construction
- Included inserts
Never authenticate an expensive record from the front cover alone.
Different pressings can use nearly identical artwork.
Which Version Should You Buy?
It depends on why you want it.
If you mainly want to listen to the album, the regular black 2LP makes much more sense. It gives you the complete record without requiring you to pay a collector premium.
If you are building a serious Logic collection, the 2016 Record Store Day picture disc is far more interesting.
It has a documented production quantity of just 2,000 copies, a distinctive visual presentation and a direct connection to Record Store Day 2016.
There is also a middle ground.
You can buy the regular pressing now and wait patiently for a reasonably priced RSD copy. Collecting becomes expensive when excitement turns into urgency.
Rare does not mean you must buy the first copy you see.
What Is the Rarest Vinyl Record Ever?
There is no universally agreed answer because collectors use the word rare in different ways.
Does rare mean only one copy exists? Does it mean very few were commercially pressed? Or does it mean almost no copies survive today?
One extraordinary example is a 1958 recording by The Quarrymen, the group featuring John Lennon, Paul McCartney and George Harrison before The Beatles.
Guinness World Records describes the only known copy of their recording of That’ll Be the Day backed with In Spite of All the Danger as the world’s most valuable vinyl-record single in its record category, with an estimated value of £100,000 at the time of its listing. Paul McCartney eventually acquired the original recording.
There is a technical wrinkle: the historic disc is an acetate, rather than a conventional mass-produced vinyl pressing.
That is why claims about the single rarest vinyl record should always be treated carefully.
Another famous rarity mentioned by Guinness is the withdrawn A&M pressing of the Sex Pistols’ God Save the Queen. Only around 300 copies were believed to exist.
So there is no neat one-record answer that covers every definition of rare.
Which Vinyl Album Is Worth the Most Money?
One of the clearest verified records belongs to The Beatles’ White Album.
Ringo Starr owned copy No. 0000001, a mono first pressing carrying the lowest possible numbered cover.
It sold at Julien’s Auctions in Los Angeles on December 5, 2015 for $790,000.
Guinness World Records lists that transaction as the record for the most expensive vinyl record sold at auction.
The price was not simply about the music.
It combined several collector factors at once:
- The Beatles
- First pressing
- Serial number 0000001
- Ringo Starr’s ownership
- Near-mint condition
- Documented provenance
That is a useful lesson for anyone valuing The Incredible True Story.
Rarity alone does not determine price. Rarity plus demand, condition, provenance and cultural importance creates serious value.
Does Travis Scott Have Vinyl Records?
Yes.
Travis Scott has released multiple albums on vinyl.
His official Utopia site displays several vinyl variants numbered Utopia Vinyl 01 through Vinyl 05.
Sony’s official stores have also offered Utopia on 2LP vinyl and list Astroworld as a vinyl release.
There have even been special and limited-edition Utopia vinyl releases.
This does not directly affect the value of Logic’s record, but it reflects something bigger happening in modern hip-hop. Vinyl is no longer limited to collectors of old rock, jazz or soul records. Major rap albums now routinely receive standard pressings, colored editions, picture discs and limited variants.
Those different editions can later create very different collector markets.
A Quick Checklist Before Buying The Incredible True Story Vinyl
Before spending money, especially on an expensive picture-disc copy, check:
- Is it the regular black 2LP or the Record Store Day picture disc?
- Does the catalog number match the claimed pressing?
- Are clear photos of the actual record provided?
- Can you see the sleeve edges and corners?
- Has the seller described scratches or warping?
- Are the runout markings visible or available on request?
- Does the seller have a reliable transaction history?
- Have you checked recent completed sales?
- Is the asking price based on real demand or simply the word rare?
One more thing matters: avoid paying RSD prices for the standard release.
Because the ordinary 2LP remains commercially available, sellers should not be able to turn a normal copy into a supposedly scarce collectible simply by adding words such as rare, original or limited to a listing.
Verify first. Pay second.
Why This Logic Record Works So Well as a Collectible
The appeal of The Incredible True Story Vinyl goes beyond scarcity.
Logic made an album meant to feel like a journey. The spoken scenes, the search for Paradise, the transitions between songs and the cinematic structure reward uninterrupted listening. On vinyl, that experience becomes physical. You turn the record over and continue the story.
For most fans, the standard 2LP is enough. It contains the complete album, remains obtainable and lets you experience the record without worrying about protecting an expensive collectible.
For serious Logic collectors, however, the 2,000-copy Record Store Day picture disc is the one that stands apart.
That is the copy with documented scarcity.
And that distinction is what matters most: owning The Incredible True Story on vinyl is easy; owning one of its genuinely limited editions is something different.
Jessica Savitch, with a deep passion for journalism, brings her expertise to istruestory.com as a dedicated author. MA in Arts & Journalism.